[Verse 1]
Do you remember back in December
Him in your sweater and he wore it better
Than I’d ever try to, I see how he likes you
The same way that I do
But I bite my tongue as you

[Pre-Chorus]
Watch him
Your gaze is so daunting
I could never be him
The way you pretend is so haunting
But I know you want him

[Chorus]
I know that when you kiss me
It's him that you’re always missing
You gave me your sweater
But what’s polyester
When we are together
But you like him better?

[Verse 2]
He steals your glances as I hold your hand, oh
Our halfhearted dancing, but I understand
'Cause he’s all I could not be
Does he make you happy?
I’m grasping at strings
And I fall to my knees as I

[Pre-Chorus 2]
Beg you
Tell me, what can I do?
I don’t wanna lose you
But it’s clear that he chooses you
And you do too

[Chorus]
I know that when you kiss me
It's him who you’re always missing
You gave me your sweater
But what’s polyester
When we are together
But you like him better?

[Bridge]
You like him better
Sucks to be Heather
You like him better

[Chorus]
I know that when you kiss me
He’s the one you wish I’d be
You gave me your sweater
But what’s polyester
When we are together
But you like him better