[Verse 1]
Somewhere deep inside of a stranger's eyes
There are stranger things I see
Shades of light on a secret part of me
Living in the shadows hiding from my life
I was waiting for a dream
Now a perfect stranger fills my needs

[Chorus]
Thief of Hearts
Stole my heart from me
Thief of Hearts
Better than a dream
The Thief of Hearts

[Verse 2]
Hands upon my body full of cool control
Baby, tell me how you knew
Everything that felt so good to me
Now I see you clearer through your one-way mirror
Real, but too surreal
Turn the pages, you're a memory

[Chorus]
Thief of Hearts
Stole my heart from me
Thief of Hearts
Better than a dream
The Thief of Hearts
[Bridge]
When I think about my soul
All the secrets that you stole
Then I know that I've just got to let you go (I've got to let you go)

[Chorus]
Thief of Hearts
Stole my heart from me
Thief of Hearts
Better than a dream
The Thief of Hearts

[Instrumental Interlude]

[Chorus]
Thief of Hearts
Stole my heart from me
Thief of Hearts
Better than a dream
Thief of Hearts
Stole my heart from me
Thief of Hearts
Better than a dream
Thief of Hearts