[Verse 1]
Where do I look when someone's serenading me?
I look him in the eyes and it feels really awkward
Am I supposed to stare at him the entire song?
If I look away, will he know I'm bored?

Can't he just look beyond the horizon
Like a cowboy in a Folger's commercial
Or close his eyes like he's feeling real deep
So I can close my eyes like I'm going to sleep

[Chorus]
Hey girl
Hey girl
Hey girl in the moonlight

[Verse 2]
Why doesn't he break eye contact
Doesn't he feel stupid singing at me like that?
He plays guitar as well as me
And that's not saying much
He sings like he's in 1983
Like Richard Marx, but tough

[Chorus]
Hey girl
Hey girl
Hey girl in the moonlight
Everybody!

Hey girl
Hey girl
Hey girl in the moonlight

[Outro]
Where do I look when someone's serenading at me
I look him in the eyes and it feels really awkward

Hey girl in the moonlight