[Verse 1]
Judy and me, every week
Would buy a ticket for the Wednesday night lottery
She'd pick the numbers, I'd pick it up
Would it feel different if I was holding the winning one?

[Chorus]
What would you buy?
I'd buy a ticket for the Thursday night and try to win twice

[Verse 2]
Judy and me, every week
Would order doubles 'til the numbers were released
I wanted to pick them one week
But I swore that'd be the week that they pick her numbers

[Chorus]
What would you buy?
I'd buy a ticket for the Thursday night and try to win twice

[Verse 3]
Judy and me, every time
Would get our hopes up a little too high
Judy and me would squint our eyes to read the numbers and say "Maybe next time"

[Outro]
What would you buy?
I'd buy a ticket for the Thursday night
What would you buy?
I'd buy a ticket for the Thursday night and try to win twice