[Verse 1]
I think she considers me an acquired taste
With a short shelf life
Like an aging prodigy desperate for a discovery
So I’m looking through my old notebooks
Trying to find a feeling
I recall to be appealing early in my life

[Chorus]
When they told me about salvation
I told them they were wrong
But as I stand here shaking, oh, I pray I’m not alone

[Verse 2]
I know what I’m about to say makes me sound like such a jerk
And I knew what she was thinking so I walked out of the door
Now I’m thumbing through my contact list
Trying to find a friend to call
I dial Matt Agrella and it goes straight to voice mail
So I drove down to the Naples Pier
And I walked out to the end
I take a picture I’ve taken a thousand times
And drove back home again

[Chorus]
When they told me about salvation
I told them they were wrong
But as I stand here shaking, oh, I pray I’m not alone
Yes, I pray I'm not alone
[Bridge]
She asked me once again if I’m losing my interest
I think perhaps that question is for you my dear
'Cause I love you more than I ever have
And I don’t want to believe that one of us is drifting
And this time it isn’t me

[Chorus]
When they told me about salvation
I told them they were wrong
But as I stand here shaking, oh, I pray I’m not alone
They told me about salvation
And I still think they were wrong
But as I stand here shaking, oh, I pray I’m not alone
Yes, I pray I'm not alone
Yes, I pray I'm not alone
Yes, I pray I'm not alone