[Verse 1]
I'm not the kind of fool who's gonna sit and sing to you
About stars, girl
But last night I looked up into the dark half of the blue
And they'd gone backwards

[Pre-Chorus]
Something in your magnetism must have pissed them off
Forcing them to get an early night
I have been searching from the bottom to the top
For such a sight as the one I caught when I saw your

[Chorus]
Fingers dimming the lights
Like you're used to being told that you're trouble
And I spent all night
Stuck on the puzzle

[Verse 2]
Nobody I asked knew how he came to be the one to whom
You surrendered
Any man who wasn't led away into the other room
Stood pretending

[Pre-Chorus]
That something in your magnetism hadn't just made him drop
Whoever's hand it was that he was holding
I have been searching from the bottom to the top
For such a sight as the one I caught when I saw your
[Chorus]
Fingers dimming the lights
Like you're used to being told that you're trouble
And I spent all night
Stuck on the puzzle

[Outro]
I tried to swim to the side
But my feet got caught in the middle
And I thought I'd seen the light
But oh, no
I was just stuck on the puzzle
Stuck on the puzzle