Here’s where, here's where the horror hits home
I figured it all out on my own
Heaven is what-what you make it
Hell is what-what you’re putting me through
Out there, out there, waiting unknown
I get the feeling you’re not alone
How could you? Why would you? Who told you?

And now I know the story before you tell me
Tell me, what were you thinking?
I know I’m not the only one
So funny so
You call it your little secret
I’m sorry I couldn’t keep it
I know I’m not the only one

Midnight, midnight, a cigarette burns
Sliding off the bed and out the door
Heaven is what-what you make it
Hell is what-what you’re putting me through
Goodbye, goodbye, you wasted my time
You were the best part of my life
How could you? Why would you? Who told you?

And now I know the story before you tell me
Tell me, what were you thinking?
I know I’m not the only one
So funny so
You call it your little secret
I’m sorry I couldn’t keep it
I know I’m not the only one
One and only
I know I’m not the only one, only one
L-I before the E
Fell for it
I can’t believe I fell for it
Lucky for me, I’m not the only one

L-I before the E
Fell for it
I can’t believe I fell for it
Lucky for me, I’m not the only one

Who knows the story before you tell me?
Tell me, what were you thinking?
I know I’m not the only one

And now I know the story before you tell me
Tell me, what were you thinking?
I know I’m not the only one
So funny so
You call it your little secret
I’m sorry I couldn’t keep it
I know I’m not the only one
One and only
I know I’m not the only one