It's like we both had just arrived here
Like we both stepped off a plane in a new town
And the sun was out

I would talk and you would point your ear at me
Like I was making some sweet sound
You said to make it loud

But we can never come back here again
We can only hope to forget

Walked through a cemetery archway
To a wood that hummed so happily along
But the words were all wrong

You traded all my imperfections
For directions to a party across town
You bring the house down

But we can never go back there again
We can only hope

So, burned is the house, gone is the street
Here is the same disappointing retreat
And I need it like hell, if I'd lie to myself
To think I could live that life over again
With a cuss word like 'guilt', and the taste for your eyes
As they well up when I couldn't just say goodnight
If you'd cry me a river you could baptize me in
I'd say I guess that's it, now I've fucking seen everything

You were the first real choice I would make
But we all make mistakes

Jumped overboard because the water's always greener
When the sun shines on the sea
Would you drown for me?

It's just as deep as you can make it
You tread water when you could stand on your knees
But don't pray to me

Cause when the lamprey's taken all it can
He will you leave you dead

But, but burned is the house, gone is the street
Here is the same disappointing retreat
And I need it like hell, if I'd lie to myself
To think I could live that life over again

With a cuss word like 'guilt', and the taste for your eyes
As they well up when I couldn't just say goodnight
If you'd cry me a river you could baptize me in
I'd say I guess that's it, yeah I've fucking seen everything, now
You were the first real choice I would make
You were the only one that I would take, now you'll take til I go

You were the first real choice I would make
But we all make mistakes, oh