[Verse 1]
Once you share it all, it's not yours anymore
You could lose hope thinking like that
Careful, careful what you wish for
It could come true, thinking like that

[Chorus]
Why'd you go overthinking like that?
Did you go overthinking?

[Verse 2]
We struck up at the stroke of midnight
Wouldn't dare cross it, but I stare at the line
We get caught stargazing on sunset
For weeks on end at a time
Come on, say the thing that you're singing about me
If that'll do you some good
Name one thing that you'd change about me
I never said that you couldn't
Come on, say the thing that you're singing about me
If that'll do you some good
Name one thing that you'd change about me
I never said that you couldn't

[Chorus]
Why'd you go overthinking like that?
Did you go overthinking?
Why'd you go overthinking like that?
Did you go overthinking?