[Verse 1]
You were the new girl dressed in a Henley
Ears with those spacers that kind of scared me
Hair in a bun and hands on a bass guitar
I was a singer leading the church band
Catching your brown eyes over the mic stand
That was the first time I learned who you are

[Chorus]
But that's not why I've bloodshot eyes
You know I'm talking 'bout those sleepless nights
We said we'd try it once
We tried it twice
Have you forgotten?
Bloodshot eyes
I don't sleep thinking about those times
Your tangled hair, we laughed
Your hands in mine
Have you forgotten?
Bloodshot

[Verse 2]
We had a meeting with some other church staff
You cracked a feminist joke and I laughed
Made them uncomfortable and I was mesmerized
We went for coffee
We went for dinner
Walked to the beach
Watched a film and you lingered
They started to question how you owned my time
[Chorus]
If they knew why I've bloodshot eyes
You know I'm talking 'bout those sleepless nights
We said we'd try it once
We tried it twice
Have you forgotten?
Bloodshot eyes
I don't sleep thinking about those times
Your tangled hair, we laughed
Your hands in mine
Have you forgotten?

[Bridge]
We don't talk about it
We keep it quiet
Don't start a riot
Oh, play it safe
But do you remember?
Ended it in September
You said forever
You left but you've got

[Chorus]
Bloodshot eyes
You know I'm talking 'bout those sleepless nights
We said we'd try it once
We tried it twice
Have you forgotten?
(Have you forgotten?)
Bloodshot eyes
I don't sleep thinking about those times (I don't sleep, no)
Your tangled hair, we laughed
Your hands in mine (Don't forget, no regrets)
Have you forgotten?
Bloodshot